Holiday cookies with hot chocolate

Cookie Exchange

December 6, 2016 – The holidays are full of magic, and the magic doesn’t stop with homemade baked goods. Spread the magic with family and friends by following these steps and recipes to host a cookie exchange that will leave you and your friends with a wide variety of baked goods to enjoy through the end of the holiday season!

Invite Your Baking-Savvy FriendsChristmas cookies with frosting.
Send invitations to up to 10 friends who would be interested in sharing their best baked goods. Have each guest bring a copy of his or her recipe, a dozen cookies (or half a dozen per guest, whichever is preferred) for each attendee and supplies to package their treats to take home.

Share the List of Recipes
To make sure you and your guests aren’t baking the same recipe, have everyone send you their recipes ahead of time and ask your guests to be flexible if you need to ask them to switch theirs.

Select a Recipe Your Friends Will Love
Choose your favorite recipe! Here are a few we think you’ll love:
Christmas CookiesChristmas cookies with Hershey Kiss center.
Cookie art is no small -feat! Put your inner-artist to the test with these decorative cookies.

Coffee Chocolate Chip Brownie Cookie

Chocolate chip cookies with a coffee kick.

Apricot Butter Fluff Cookies 
Easy-to-make with only five ingredients!

Meet zucchini bread’s tasty new cousin – the zookie!Pumpkin cranberry walnut cookies with maple glaze.

Frosty Kiss Cookies
Your guests will be waiting under the mistletoe for these.

Maple Glazed Pumpkin Cranberry Walnut Cookies
You had us at maple glazed.

Hot Cocoa Cookies
Chocolatey-rich treats for your guests that are dairy-free.

Ready, Set, Swap!
Set up a long table so guests can sample, swap and package their cookie collections. Also, make sure to offer extra wrapping materials, napkins and warm coffee or tea to keep guests refreshed between samples.

Do you have tips for a perfect cookie swap? Share it below!

Home | Previous Page

6 thoughts on “Cookie Exchange

  1. Shirley Flam

    My favorite…Winternacht Pfeffernusse Glasiert Iced Gingerbread Cookies…..Fabulous. Just stopped at my wonderful Aldi’s store tonight and purchased the last ones available for the season! I got them on sale for 75cents a bag. They are a seasonal item so I have to be very conservative to make these last as long as possible. I’m going to test freezing one bag and see how the quality is after they have been frozen. So Aldi’s….please carry this seasonal Christmas item again next year. They are a tradition in our house!!! I am so thankful to have an Aldi’s store in our area!!! The staff at our Aldi’s store in Mt. PLeasant, Iowa is super helpful and friendly….they make it a joy to shop there!!! Thank you!

  2. Trish

    Could you please make the halloween cookie recipe for all seasons. We loved them. They’re great with tea and coffee or anytime they had orange castor sugar decoration and they were round and they had a rim. Would be fantastic for Christmas . And thank you so much for the Prairie Farms Egg Nog Last year please carry it th oh s year. THANK YOU

Leave a Reply

All comments are moderated. We reserve the right to not publish any user comment that is offensive, off-topic or inappropriate. We also ask that users treat others as they would like to be treated. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *